Skip to main content

Old Mine Cut Diamond Earrings

to
60
1,411
810
432
385
371
1,569
174
153
145
133
15
556
947
259
119
100
114
101
33
60
31
38
25
8
14
1,298
495
6
760
100
73
66
42
to
19
18
14
12
8
448
264
146
119
58
56
53
46
30
7
4
4
1
1,794
5
1,029
683
Sort By
Victorian 1.80 Total Carat Mine Cut Diamond Earrings
Located in Narberth, PA
topped in sterling silver, each earring displays a glittering old Mine Cut diamond within an open-backed
Category

Antique 1880s Unknown Victorian Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold, Sterling Silver

Vintage Amethyst And Old Mine Cut Diamond Gold Earrings
Located in Cairo, EG
14k gold earrings with pear shape dangling amethyst centered with 6 old mine cut diamonds 0.17 ct
Category

Vintage 1920s Dangle Earrings

Old Mine Diamond Platinum Drop Earrings
Located in New York, NY
Made of platinum, these earrings feature sparkling old mine cut diamonds weighing approximately
Category

Early 20th Century Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Antique Emerald And Old Mine Cut Diamond Gold Earrings
Located in Cairo, EG
Antique rare Russian natural emerald diamond earrings with an estimate old mine cut diamond weight
Category

Antique 1870s Victorian Dangle Earrings

Materials

14k Gold

Victorian Old Cut Diamond Cluster Earrings
Located in London, GB
. Each piece features an array of round faceted old mine cut diamonds; each of which has been
Category

Antique 19th Century Victorian Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, Rose Gold

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond Russian Dangling Gold Earrings
Located in Cairo, EG
Antique imperial russian era 1907/1917.c 14k gold earrings with old mine cut diamonds in silver
Category

Antique Early 1900s Dangle Earrings

Victorian 18 Karat Gold TW 2.50 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond Lever-Back Earrings
Located in Vilnius, Vilniaus apskr.
. The piece features 2 old mine cut diamonds: 1.20ct and 1.30ct, G-H, P1. The gems have a stunning
Category

Antique Mid-19th Century Victorian Lever-Back Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold

Antique Victorian Old Mine Rose Cut Diamond Drop Flower Earrings
Located in London, GB
original old-mine-cut diamonds and rose-cut diamonds, all in excellent condition. Approximate total diamond
Category

Antique 1880s Unknown Edwardian Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, Silver

2 Carat Old Mine Cut Antique Diamond Stud Earrings E/F Color 100% Eye Clean
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Chicago, IL
This gorgeous and rare 2.01ctw antique matched pair of old mine cut diamonds is bright white, eye
Category

Antique Early 1900s Unknown High Victorian Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond

Earrings studs with old mine cut diamonds up to 0.70ct 18k pink gold and silver
Located in The Hague, ZH
18k pink gold with silver stud earrings set with old mine cut diamonds. 0.70ct - G/H - SI detailed
Category

2010s Dutch Early Victorian Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, Silver

Edwardian Inspired Old Mine Diamond 18K White Yellow Gold Earrings
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
Center Stone: 4 Diamonds Cut: Old Mine Cut Weight: 2.06 Carat Color: K Clarity: SI Metal: 18K
Category

20th Century Edwardian Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, White Gold, Yellow Gold

Antique Victorian 14k Yellow Gold Old Mine Diamond and Sapphire Earrings
Located in Great Neck, NY
Victorian diamond and sapphire earrings have old mine cut diamonds with a beautiful blue sapphire in the
Category

Antique 1890s Unknown Victorian Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Sapphire, Yellow Gold

Antique Inspired 6.06 Carat Old Mine Diamond 18K Yellow Gold Earrings
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
/8 inches Gram weight: 5.48 These elegant earrings feature 42 dazzling old mine cut diamonds
Category

20th Century Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold

Old Mine Diamond Pearl Dangle Drop Earrings 14 Karat Yellow Gold
Located in New York, NY
these earrings have Old Mine Cut Diamonds. The diamonds are set within target motif circles at the top
Category

20th Century Unknown Modern Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Pearl, Gold, 14k Gold, Yellow Gold

Antique Emerald And Old Mine Cut Diamond Gold Dangling Earrings
Located in Cairo, EG
weight of 5 carats and old cut diamond weight of 2.5 carats H color vs clearity total earrings length
Category

Vintage 1910s Dangle Earrings

GIA Certified 2 Carat Old Mine Cut Cushion Cut Diamond Studs D E COLOR
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Chicago, IL
2 carat antique matched pair of old mine cut diamonds is bright white, eye clean, full of old world
Category

2010s Italian Modern Clip-on Earrings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond

GIA Certified 3 Carat Old Mine Cut Cushion Cut Diamond Studs F Color
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Chicago, IL
This gorgeous and rare 3 carat antique matched pair of old mine cut diamonds is bright white, eye
Category

2010s Italian Modern Clip-on Earrings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, 14k Gold, White Gold

GIA Certified 2 Carat Old Mine Cut Cushion Cut Diamond Studs F Color
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Chicago, IL
old mine cut diamonds is bright white, eye clean, full of old world charm, and dazzling with
Category

2010s Italian Modern Clip-on Earrings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, 14k Gold, White Gold

Victorian Old Mine Diamond Dangle Drop Flower Earrings 14 Karat Gold Rare
Located in New York, NY
antique Old Mine Cut Diamonds each individually prong set along the earrings. The wonderful applied gold
Category

Antique Mid-19th Century Unknown Victorian Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 14k Gold, Yellow Gold

1880s Victorian Old Mine Cushion Diamond Gold Earrings
Located in Hicksville, NY
Type: 14k Yellow Gold Weight: 3.0g Diamond 1 Details: Size: .25 Cut: Old Mine Brilliant Color
Category

Antique 1880s Unknown High Victorian Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold

Art Deco .40 Ct Old Mine Diamond Platinum 18 KT gold Stud Earrings
Located in Napoli, IT
mine cut Diamonds of .40 Ct for both excellent rating of G VVS/VS – bright white full of sparkle
Category

Vintage 1920s European Art Deco Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, Platinum

Art Deco Diamond Dangle Screwback Earrings .46ct Old Mine 14K Original 1920 s
Located in Dearborn, MI
Screwback Earrings Features Two Genuine Natural Mined Old Mine Cut Diamonds Diamonds are Incredibly
Category

Vintage 1920s Art Deco Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold, Yellow Gold

Antique Late 19th Century Pair of Old Mine Diamond Cluster Earrings
Located in New York, NY
A classic pair of antique 19th Century cluster earrings set with old mine diamonds, circa 1880
Category

Antique Late 19th Century Unknown Late Victorian Lever-Back Earrings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold

Rare Victorian Old Mine Diamond Drop Dangle Lever Back Earrings 18K Rose Gold
Located in Fairfield, CT
Rare Victorian Old Mine Diamond Drop Dangle Lever Back Earrings 18K Rose Gold These antique
Category

Antique 1860s Victorian Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, Rose Gold

GIA 2.38 Carat Old Mine and Old European Diamond Platinum Earrings
Located in Cape May, NJ
Platinum Old Mine Old European Diamond Earrings 2.38 Carats Total What do you do with a
Category

2010s American Edwardian Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Victorian Old Mine Cut Diamond Blue Enamel 14 Karat Yellow Gold Star Earrings
Located in Philadelphia, PA
accents the edges of the star earrings. Each earring is set with an old mine diamond .36 carat total
Category

Antique 19th Century Victorian Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold

4.80ct Old Miners Cut diamond earrings studs 18KT gold RARE find
Located in Boca Raton, FL
A rare find on these beautiful earrings with some much warmth and character, they are totaling 4.30
Category

20th Century Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold

Antique Old Cut Coronet Cluster Earrings, circa 1890
Located in London, GB
Old cut diamond coronet cluster stud earrings set with nine round old cut diamonds in an open back
Category

Antique 1890s Late Victorian Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold

Antique Stud Earrings With Old European Cut Diamonds
Located in Firenze, IT
18k rose gold and platinum set with old mine-cut diamonds with an approximate total weight of 1.20
Category

Antique Late 19th Century Italian Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, Rose Gold

Two Large Old-Mine 3.20 Carat Platinum Diamond Jade Earrings
Located in New York, NY
Carved Imperial Jadeite Jade 2 Large old-mine cut diamond 1.20 Cts. each Total of large diamond
Category

Antique Mid-19th Century Art Deco Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Jade, Platinum

Art Deco Dangle Earrings 18kt Yellow Gold and Old-Cut Diamonds
Located in Esch sur Alzette, Esch-sur-Alzette
Art Deco Dangle Earrings in 18kt Yellow Gold with Old-Cut Diamonds are exquisite pieces of jewelry
Category

Early 20th Century French Art Deco Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold

Art Deco .40 Ct Old Mine Diamond Platinum 18 KT Stud
Located in Napoli, IT
Gorgeous Art Deco period Diamond studs holding .40 Ct of of old mine cut Diamonds Each Diamond is
Category

Vintage 1920s European Art Deco Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, Platinum

Antique Circa 1900s 14k Gold Natural Old Cut Diamond Decorated Solitaire Earring
Located in Fatih/İstanbul, 34
In very good condition. Total weight is 4.7 grams. Totally is diamond 1.42 ct. The diamond is has
Category

Antique Early 1900s European Victorian Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold

Art Deco 18kt Gold Earrings with Old-cut Diamonds
Located in Esch sur Alzette, Esch-sur-Alzette
The Art Deco 18kt Gold Earrings with Old-Cut Diamonds are a stunning piece of jewelry that embodies
Category

Early 20th Century French Art Deco Lever-Back Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, White Gold, Yellow Gold

Antique Victorian 14 kt Gold Halo Earrings with 0.74 ct Old-Cut Diamonds
Located in AMSTERDAM, NL
: halo earrings 4. Cut & Shape: Bolshevik cut, rose cut 5. Weight & Size: 24 rose cut diamonds- 0.24 ct
Category

Antique 1890s European Early Victorian Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 14k Gold

Belle Epoque 3.60 Ct Old Cut Diamond Platinum Drop earrings
Located in Napoli, IT
Hallmarks: none/worn Gems: 2 old European cut diamonds totalling approx 1.40 Ct (G/H-SI/I) – 10 old mine and
Category

Early 20th Century European Belle Époque Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Vintage Circa 1960s 18k Gold Natural Old Cut Diamond And Ruby Decorated Earring
Located in Fatih/İstanbul, 34
In very good condition. Total weight is 3.3 grams. Totally is diamond about 0.50 ct. The diamond is
Category

Vintage 1960s European Retro Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Ruby, 18k Gold

Edwardian Old European-Cut Diamond Gold and Silver Drop Earrings
Located in New York, NY
Edwardian Old European-Cut Diamond Drop Earrings in Silver and Gold. A magnificent pair of drop
Category

Vintage 1910s Edwardian Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, White Gold, Silver, Mixed Metal

Antique Circa 1900s 18k Gold Natural Old Cut Diamond Solitaire Earring
Located in Fatih/İstanbul, 34
In very good condition. Total weight is 1.5 grams. Totally is diamond 0.46 ct. The diamond is has J
Category

Antique Early 1900s European Victorian Clip-on Earrings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold

2.43 Carat Old Mine Diamond Thin Bar Style 3 Section Platinum Dangle Earrings
Located in Stamford, CT
1900's Handmade three section old mine diamond dangle earrings. Made in solid Platinum with simple
Category

Early 20th Century Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Antique natural pearl old cut diamond 18k yellow gold drop earrings
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
These antique drop earrings combine luminous natural pearls with sparkling old mine and rose-cut
Category

Vintage 1910s Victorian Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Pearl, Gold, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold, Platinum

Antique Cut Chocolate Diamond Free-Form Wire Pierced Earrings
Located in New York, NY
Charming Modern Antique Cut Diamond Freeform Wire Pierced Earrings' 1 carat diamonds set in vermeil
Category

2010s Indian Anglo-Indian Chandelier Earrings

Materials

Vermeil

5.08 Carat Old European Diamond Drop Dangle Platinum Earrings
Located in Chicago, IL
hard to find in old cut stones! The diamonds are 100% natural earth mined, and they have not received
Category

Vintage 1920s Italian Art Deco Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Platinum

Victorian 18 Karat Gold Old Cut Diamond Blue Enamel Star Lever-Back Earrings
Located in Vilnius, Vilniaus apskr.
adorned with blue enamel. The piece features old mine cut and rose cut diamonds. Circa 1890. Weight
Category

Antique Late 19th Century Victorian Lever-Back Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, Enamel

Antique Rose Cut Diamond Earrings
Located in Chicago, IL
are bright white old mine diamonds in buttercup settings (approximately 0.30 ct tw). The stylized
Category

Antique Late 19th Century Victorian Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond

Edwardian Diamond Stud Earrings
Located in Litchfield, CT
), these antique earrings are a rare find. The early mine-cut diamonds have a subtle visual quality. They
Category

Vintage 1910s Edwardian Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Antique Diamond Dormeuses Earrings
Located in Geneva, CH
Antique Diamond Dormeuses Earrings. Old mine cut diamond on gold. Early 20th Century. Dimensions
Category

Early 20th Century European Art Nouveau Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold

1960s Diamond Platinum Cluster Stud Earrings
Located in Napoli, NA
large Old mine cut Diamonds in the center and surrounded by 6 diamonds for a total weight of 0.80 ct
Category

Vintage 1950s Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Victorian Old Cut Diamond Bell Drop Earrings Set in 18 Karat Rose and White Gold
Located in London, England
). Each earring consists of a mixture of rose cut and old mine cut diamonds which when combined have an
Category

Antique Early 1900s Unknown Late Victorian Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, Rose Gold, White Gold

Victorian Diamond and Onyx Earrings
Located in Narberth, PA
yellow gold, each earring adorns three sparkling old Mine Cut diamonds that form a simple, yet beautiful
Category

Antique 1880s Victorian Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Onyx, 15k Gold

Victorian Blue Enamel and Diamond Earrings
Located in London, GB
identical and presents an open undulating double frame which surrounds an impressive chunky old mine cut
Category

Antique 19th Century Victorian Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, Enamel

Art Deco Old European Diamond Drop Dangle Earrings 18 Karat White Gold Estate
Located in Boca Raton, FL
Old Mine and Old European cut diamonds weighing approximately 2.00 carat total weight. The diamonds
Category

Early 20th Century Unknown Art Deco Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, White Gold

Antique Drop Earrings in 18kt Gold with Diamonds
Located in Aventura, FL
center old mine natural diamonds together weighing approximately 0.28 carats (H color, VS2 clarity). The
Category

20th Century Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold

Estate 18k Diamond Stud Earrings
Located in Narberth, PA
mine cut diamond held within a milgrained bezel-setting. Together, the diamonds have an approximate
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Modern Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, White Gold

Vintage Pearl Diamond Gold Drop Earrings
Located in Los Angeles, CA
: ten old cut diamonds totaling approximately 0.42 carat. METAL: 14-karat gold. EARRINGS BACKS: post
Category

Vintage 1930s Retro Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Pearl, Gold, 14k Gold

Black and White Enamel Pendant Diamond and Platinum Earrings
Located in New York, NY
trio of charming mine-cut diamonds, with a larger, bezel-set diamond at the base of the drop. The
Category

Vintage 1930s French Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Victorian 1890s Diamond Two-Tone Gold Drop Earrings
Located in Los Angeles, CA
Victorian 1890s diamond and two-tone gold drop earrings. Featuring a pair of old mine-cut diamonds
Category

Antique 1890s Victorian Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold

  • 1
  • ...
Get Updated with New Arrivals
Save "Old Mine Cut Diamond Earrings", and we’ll notify you when there are new listings in this category.

Old Mine Cut Diamond Earrings For Sale on 1stDibs

Find an expansive variety of old mine cut diamond earrings available on 1stDibs. These distinct designs — crafted with great care and often made from Gold, 18k Gold and Platinum — can elevate any look. Our collection of these items for sale includes 105 vintage editions and 39 modern creations to choose from as well. Our collection is diverse and broad-ranging, and pieces in stock date back to the 18th Century while others were produced as recently as the 21st Century. Victorian and Art Deco are consistently popular styles when it comes to old mine cut diamond earrings. Versions of these items have been a part of the life’s work for many jewelers, but those produced by Single Stone, Mark Broumand and Antinori Fine Jewels are consistently popular. Today, if you’re looking for old mine cut old mine cut diamond earrings and are unable to find the perfect match, our selection also includes pear cut and cushion cut alternatives. If you’re browsing the variety of old mine cut diamond earrings for sale, you’ll find that many are available today for women, but there are still pieces to choose from for men.

How Much are Old Mine Cut Diamond Earrings?

Prices for old mine cut diamond earrings can differ depending upon size, time period and other attributes — at 1stDibs, these accessories begin at $200 and can go as high as $148,642, while old mine cut diamond earrings, on average, fetch $9,838.

The Legacy of Diamond in Jewelry Design

Antique diamond rings, diamond tiaras and dazzling vintage diamond earrings are on the wish lists of every lover of fine jewelry. And diamonds and diamond jewelry are primarily associated with storybook engagements and red-carpet grand entrances — indeed, this ultra-cherished gemstone has a dramatic history on its hands.

From “A Diamond Is Forever” to “Diamonds Are a Girl’s Best Friend,” pop culture has ingrained in our minds that diamonds are the most desired, the most lasting and the most valuable gemstone. But what makes the diamond so special? Each stone — whether it’s rubies, sapphires or another stone — is unique and important in its own right. April babies might claim diamonds for themselves, but just about everyone wants this kind of sparkle in their lives!

There are several factors that set diamonds apart from other stones, and these points are important to our gem education.

Diamonds are minerals. They are made up of almost entirely of carbon (carbon comprises 99.95 percent; the remainder consists of various trace elements). Diamonds are the hardest gemstones, ranking number 10 on the Mohs Hardness Scale. Even its name, diamond, is rooted in the Greek adamas, or unconquerable. The only object that can scratch a diamond is another diamond. Diamonds are formed deep within the earth at very high temperatures (1,652–2,372 degrees Fahrenheit at depths between 90 and 120 miles beneath the earth’s surface) and are carried up by volcanic activity. Diamonds are quite rare, according to the Gemological Institute of America, and only 30 percent of all the diamonds mined in the world are gem quality.

In the 1950s, the Gemological Institute of America developed the 4Cs grading system to classify diamonds: clarity, color, cut and carat weight. Not all diamonds are created equal (there are diamonds, and then there are diamonds). The value of the diamond depends on the clarity (flawless diamonds are very rare but a diamond's value decreases if there are many blemishes or inclusions), color (the less color the higher the grade), cut (how the diamond’s facets catch the light, certain cuts of diamonds show off the stone better than others) and carat weight (the bigger, the better).

When you start shopping for a diamond engagement ring, always prioritize the cut, which plays the largest role in the diamond's beauty (taking the time to clean your diamond ring at least every six months or so plays a role in maintaining said beauty). And on 1stDibs, a range of buying guides can be found for those in the market for antique engagement ringsvintage engagement rings or Art Deco engagement rings

Shop antique and vintage diamond rings, diamond necklaces and other extraordinary diamond jewelry on 1stDibs.  

Finding the Right Earrings for You

In the United States, ear piercing didn’t really become popular until the 1950s and ‘60s, but our desire for a dazzling pair of vintage earrings has deeper roots than that. In fact, wearing earrings actually goes back thousands of years, and you can find many tangible connections between now and then in how we continue to talk about these treasured accessories.

Women wore ornamental earrings — studs and hoops at the very least — in Ancient Egypt, which is home to mines that are among the earliest sources of emeralds in the world. Emerald earrings are highly prized today, and their quality lies in their rich, saturated color. The highest-quality emeralds are green or bluish-green. Earrings worn by the affluent in early Roman civilizations were set with precious stones such as diamonds and pearls, and a clean-looking pop of pearl on the front of the lobe is as timeless as ever. Hoop earrings are imbued with symbolism and cultural significance for many, and on view in the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s Ancient Near Eastern Art Gallery is a pair of simple gold hoops from Mesopotamia dating to between 2600 and 2500 B.C.

Today, ear piercing is very popular all over the world, and, as a result, it is difficult to overstate how much everyone pines for a good pair of earrings — modernist drop earrings, glamorous Victorian hoops, geometrically complex chandelier earrings, you name it. Sure, jewelry trends and the fashion darlings of social media come and go, but earrings have a staying power that seems impenetrable: The still-strong love affair between British royals and Cartier earrings is more than a century old, glossy 1970s hoops from legacy houses such as Bulgari and Van Cleef Arpels remain the statement makers they’ve always been and although people have been stacking earrings for many moons, the allure of an expertly mismatched stack of charms and studs still feels fresh and new.

While there is no shortage of modern earring designs to choose from, the classics, like coral earrings, Art Deco–style earrings and diamond drop earrings are still heavy hitters. On 1stDibs, find a wide range of antique, new and vintage earrings today.

Questions About Old Mine Cut Diamond Earrings
  • 1stDibs ExpertApril 5, 2022
    Jewelry makers stopped using the old European cut for diamond and other gemstone jewelry around 1930. The style was common during the Art Deco period, but the brilliant cut became popular in the years that followed. On 1stDibs, shop a selection of Old European cut diamond gemstone jewelry.
  • 1stDibs ExpertApril 5, 2022
    Mine cut diamonds are up to 300 years ago. Mine cut diamonds were popular around the 18th century during Victorian times and are still in high demand today. You’ll find a wide selection of mine cut diamond jewelry on 1stDibs.
  • 1stDibs ExpertFebruary 22, 2021
    Because the old mine cut is no longer used on diamonds, diamonds with this cut are rare and so you can often get quite a lot of money for them. Nevertheless, it is still dependent on the quality of the individual diamonds and on the color, clarity, cut and carat number.
  • 1stDibs ExpertFebruary 22, 2021
    Old mine cut diamonds are usually worth less than old european cut diamonds. Because they are generally 10-15% less expensive, they are often larger than other cut diamonds for engagement rings.
  • Like any other diamond, an old mine cut diamond's worth depends on a variety of factors. These factors include the 4C's (color, clarity, cut, carat), the overall beauty and "make" of the stone, the demand, supply, etc. On average however, old mine cuts are typically priced slightly lower (around 5-10%) than modern cut diamonds.