Skip to main content

Silver Black Earrings

to
154
779
236
832
319
275
146
69
43
32
23
22
22
15
14
12
10
9
9
8
6
5
4
3
3
3
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
46
43
34
20
20
Sort By
Amedeo Fauno Cameo Couture Mother-of-Pearl Earrings
By AMEDEO
Located in New York, NY
45mm sardonyx shell cameo hand-carved, set in sterling silver, black rhodium plated with 0.80ct
Category

2010s Italian Modern Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Black Diamond, Sterling Silver

Ed Wiener Mid-Century Modernist Earrings with Coral Beads
By Ed Wiener
Located in Winnetka, IL
Hand-wrought sterling silver earrings with original patina attributed to Ed Wiener. A fine example
Category

Vintage 1950s American Modernist More Earrings

Materials

Coral, Sterling Silver

Amedeo "Gorgoneion" Cameo Earrings with Diamonds and Mother of Pearl
By AMEDEO
Located in New York, NY
45mm sardonyx shell cameos featuring "Gorgoneion", set on sterling silver black rhodium with mother
Category

2010s Italian Artisan Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Black Diamond, Sterling Silver

Inverted Diamond Hoops with Round Diamonds in Sterling Silver
By Dorian Webb
Located in Oakland, CA
. Particulars: sterling silver; 2mm diamonds: white, salt and pepper, black; 0.96 total carat weight, 2.25
Category

2010s Indian Contemporary Hoop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Black Diamond, Sterling Silver

1940s Vintage Early Minimalist Garnet Pendant Necklace Earrings Set Gift Ideas
Located in Champions State Gate, FL
silver, this stunning vintage red jewelry set includes dangling threaded post earrings, with screw on
Category

Vintage 1940s Unknown Modernist Dangle Earrings

Materials

Garnet, Sterling Silver

STATEMENT Paris , Unit Hoop Stairway Cone Gradiant Diamonds Silver 0.25 Carat
Located in PARIS, FR
carat. This conical-shaped hoop is made of rhodium plated sterling silver paved with white and black
Category

21st Century and Contemporary French Contemporary Hoop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Black Diamond, Rhodium, Silver

Rock Lily ( NEW ) Pearl Peach Moonstone Detachable Tassel Stud Drop Earrings
By Rock Lily Collection
Located in Brooklyn, NY
moonstone & black cultured pearls, connected by a sterling silver chain tassel in these stunning two-in-one
Category

2010s American Contemporary Stud Earrings

Materials

Moonstone, Multi-gemstone, Pearl, Black Pearl, Cultured Pearl, Freshwate...

Rock Lily ( NEW )Cultured Pearl Moonstone Detachable Tassel Stud Drop Earrings
By Rock Lily Collection
Located in Brooklyn, NY
moonstone with pink & black cultured pearls, connected by a sterling silver chain tassel in these stunning
Category

2010s American Contemporary Stud Earrings

Materials

Pearl, Black Pearl, Cultured Pearl, Freshwater Pearl, Natural Pearl, Moo...

Yesterday s Tomorrow - DuoTone Ring black-gold
Located in London, Greater London
By simulating the sensation of magma flow, our design incorporates various hues of gold, black, and
Category

2010s British Artist Stud Earrings

Materials

Pearl, Freshwater Pearl, Spinel, 18k Gold, Rhodium, Sterling Silver

Black Tourmaline and Diamond Gold Plated Pendant Necklace by Cristina Ramella
By Cristina Ramella
Located in Newark, DE
This unique one of a kind necklace was designed and hand made back in 2006 by Cristina Ramella herself. Its made around a unique and raw tourmaline stone purchased in NYC with a spec...
Category

2010s Drop Earrings

Materials

Tourmaline, Diamond, Gold Plate, Silver

1980 s Stephen Dweck Clip-on Hematite Earrings
By Stephen Dweck
Located in San Francisco, CA
sparkling faceted clip-on earrings were originally purchased at Bergdorf Goodman. Photography provided by
Category

Vintage 1980s Clip-on Earrings

Materials

Sterling Silver

Yesterday s Tomorrow - Pearl flowing necklace black-gold
Located in London, Greater London
By simulating the sensation of magma flow, our design incorporates various hues of gold, black, and
Category

2010s British Artist Stud Earrings

Materials

Pearl, Freshwater Pearl, 18k Gold, Rhodium, Sterling Silver

Yesterday s Tomorrow - Complicated dropping necklace black-gold
Located in London, Greater London
By simulating the sensation of magma flow, our design incorporates various hues of gold, black, and
Category

2010s British Artist Stud Earrings

Materials

Pearl, Freshwater Pearl, Spinel, 18k Gold, Rhodium, Sterling Silver

Yesterday s Tomorrow - Single dropped-down necklace black
Located in London, Greater London
By simulating the sensation of magma flow, our design incorporates various hues of gold, black, and
Category

2010s British Artist Stud Earrings

Materials

Pearl, Freshwater Pearl, Spinel, 18k Gold, Rhodium, Sterling Silver

Silver and Floral Enamel Brooch and Clip-On Earrings Set
Located in London, London
Silver and floral enamel brooch and clip-on earrings set.
Category

Vintage 1940s Sterling Silver

Materials

Silver, Enamel

Rock Lily ( NEW ) Cultured Baroque Pearl 14K White 2 Stars Diamond Stud Earrings
By Rock Lily Collection
Located in Brooklyn, NY
This black baroque cultured massive pearls that made up stud earring. On front sides with 12 mm
Category

2010s American Contemporary Stud Earrings

Materials

Pearl, Black Pearl, Cultured Pearl, Freshwater Pearl, Natural Pearl, Dia...

John Hardy Carved Chain Stud Earring EBS903924BLSBN
By John Hardy
Located in Wilmington, DE
7mm sterling silver stud earrings with treated black sapphire and black spinel from John Hardy's
Category

2010s Stud Earrings

Rock Lily ( NEW ) Cultured Baroque Pearl 14K Rose 3 Stars Diamond Stud Earrings
By Rock Lily Collection
Located in Brooklyn, NY
This black baroque cultured massive pearls that made up stud earring. On front sides, 12 mm diamond
Category

2010s American Contemporary Stud Earrings

Materials

Pearl, Cultured Pearl, Freshwater Pearl, Natural Pearl, Black Pearl, Dia...

White Gray and Black Sapphire Ombre Blossom Gentile Medium Gemstone Hoops
By KATHRYN New York
Located in New York, NY
Designed in NYC .925 Sterling Silver 10 x 7 mm White Gray and Black Sapphire Ombre Blossom Medium
Category

2010s Chinese Modern Hoop Earrings

Materials

Sapphire, Sterling Silver

Rhinestone Earrings in shades of green and Grey Clips
Located in Boca Raton, FL
These beautiful Half Moon Rhinestone Earrings age clipped and in excellent vintage condition
Category

Mid-20th Century American Clip-on Earrings

Materials

Silver Plate

White Topaz and Black Spinel Ombre Blossom Gentile Large Gemstone Hoops
By KATHRYN New York
Located in New York, NY
Designed in NYC .925 Sterling Silver 15 x 7 mm White Topaz and Black Spinel Ombre Blossom Large
Category

2010s Chinese Modern Hoop Earrings

Materials

Spinel, Topaz, Sterling Silver

Black Spinel and White Topaz Medium Mismatched Blossom Gemstone Hoops
By KATHRYN New York
Located in New York, NY
Designed in NYC .925 Sterling Silver 10 x gemstones Black Spinel and White Topaz Medium Mismatched
Category

2010s Chinese Modern Hoop Earrings

Materials

Spinel, Topaz, Sterling Silver

Circa 1940s Carved Jade, Sterling and 14k Clip-Back Earrings
Located in Long Beach, CA
Circa 1940s jade oval earrings with a carved floral motif, bezel set in gold-plated sterling mounts
Category

Vintage 1940s Clip-on Earrings

Materials

Jade, 14k Gold, Sterling Silver

Studio Greytak Larimar Earrings on Amethyst With Opal and Apitite
By Studio Greytak
Located in Missoula, MT
LARIMAR EARRINGS ON AMETHYST No other stone so completely captures the exact teal and turquoise
Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Modern Lever-Back Earrings

Materials

Amethyst, Opal, Larimar, Silver

Studio Greytak Boulder Opal Earrings on Copper Amethyst, Citrine, Peridot
By Studio Greytak
Located in Missoula, MT
MATERIALS Boulder Opal Amethyst Citrine Peridot Copper Silver
Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Modern Lever-Back Earrings

Materials

Amethyst, Citrine, Opal, Peridot, Silver, Copper

Hemmerle Diamond Black Gold Ear Pendants
By Hemmerle
Located in New York, NY
a total of 3.77 carats, mounted in black finished silver and white gold, signed Hemmerle.
Category

21st Century and Contemporary German Clip-on Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, Silver

Tahitian Pearl French Enamel Studs
Located in New York, NY
. Handmade with precision and care, this piece is crafted in pure silver, ensuring durability and a timeless
Category

2010s Indian Stud Earrings

Materials

Pearl, Black Pearl, Silver, Enamel

Vintage Black Onyx Pendant and Earrings Sterling Silver Set
Located in Chesterland, OH
The exquisite laconic jewelry set is composed of natural black onyx and sterling silver. This set
Category

Late 20th Century Pendant Necklaces

Materials

Onyx, Sterling Silver

Vintage Niello Sterling Silver Charm Bracelet Earrings
Located in New York, NY
black mixture, usually of sulphur, copper, silver and lead, used as an inlay on engraved or etched metal
Category

Mid-20th Century Charm Bracelets

Materials

Sterling Silver

Salvador Teran Sterling Silver Modernist Earrings Taxco
By Salvador Teran
Located in New York, NY
Being offered are circa 1960 vintage screwback earrings by Salvador Teran of Taxco, Mexco, in an
Category

Vintage 1960s Mexican Cufflinks

Materials

Sterling Silver

Jay Tuttle Sterling Silver Modernist Earrings and Brooch
By Jay Tuttle
Located in Sacramento, CA
Stunning set of modernist sterling silver, post-threaded earrings and brooch pin. These highly
Category

Vintage 1960s American Mid-Century Modern Collectible Jewelry

Materials

Sterling Silver

Rare William Spratling Sterling Silver Shell Fish Motif Earrings 1945
By William Spratling
Located in New York, NY
Being offered are a pair of circa 1945 sterling silver and shell earrings by William Spratling of
Category

Vintage 1960s Mexican Brooches

Materials

Sterling Silver

Exolette Black Onyx Sterling Pendant Necklace Earring Set
By Samuel Edwards Jewelry Design
Located in Pahrump, NV
This black onyx and sterling pendant necklace with matching earrings is a classic assemblage of my
Category

Mid-20th Century American Gothic Revival Pendant Necklaces

Materials

Onyx, Sterling Silver

Vintage Signed Monet Silver Dangle Earrings Brooch
By Monet
Located in New York, NY
This vintage signed Monet set features multiple bottle-shaped drops in a silver-plated base metal
Category

Vintage 1950s American Brooches

Black and White Enamel Painted Square Earring
Located in Taos, FR
Artist Kyla Katz hand paints the pendant with black and white enamel and then fires it at high
Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Contemporary Pendant Necklaces

Materials

Gold, 18k Gold, Rose Gold, White Gold, Yellow Gold, Silver, Sterling Sil...

Sylvia Gottwald, Blister Pearl /Silver , Eco-Luxe Necklace /Belt Earrings Set .
By Sylvia Gottwald
Located in Washington DC, DC
mesh. The Blister pearl Earrings are set in a Silver frame on top of black Onyx circles. This object
Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Contemporary Pendant Necklaces

Materials

Onyx, Pearl, Black Pearl, Silver, Stainless Steel

SYLVIA GOTTWALD, Brown Nacre Silver French Deco Brooch Ring and Earring Set .
By Sylvia Gottwald
Located in Washington DC, DC
shades of green, gray, brown and silver. Black MOP is eco-friendly, sourced from sustainable pearl farms
Category

21st Century and Contemporary French Contemporary Brooches

Materials

Crystal, Silver

18 Karat White Gold and Sterling Silver Angel Brooch and Earring Jackets
By Llyn strong
Located in Greenville, SC
earring jackets. This Brooch designed and made by llyn strong. Comes with stand. Shown with Black Diamond
Category

2010s American Art Nouveau Brooches

Materials

White Diamond, Black Pearl, Cultured Pearl, Quartz, 18k Gold, White Gold...

Stephen Dweck Extravagant Collar with Matching Earrings
By Stephen Dweck
Located in Los Angeles, CA
pearl and sterling silver with matching oversize drop earrings with carved fish. Necklace has silver
Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Modern More Jewelry

Materials

Sterling Silver

1940s Runway Pair Onyx Diamente Sterling Chandelier Earrings
Located in West Palm Beach, FL
Large Impressive Haute Couture 4 3/4 in. Drop Runway Earrings-sterling silver, Onyx black stones
Category

Vintage 1940s Hollywood Regency Collectible Jewelry

Materials

Onyx, Sterling Silver

Moonlight Midnight Ocean Birthday Party Necklace and Moonlight Shell Earrings
By H.H. Prince John Landrum Bryant
Located in New York, NY
. Diameter of Necklace: 41cm. Earrings: Oxidized Sterling Silver. Purple Diamonds. Mother-of-Pearl. Earring
Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Contemporary Link Necklaces

Materials

White Diamond, Black Diamond, Pearl, 18k Gold, Rose Gold, Yellow Gold, P...

Robin Waynee, Black Spinel, VS1 Diamonds, 18 Karat Gold, Onyx Point Earrings
By Robin Waynee
Located in Santa Fe, NM
Robin Waynee Onyx Point Earrings, 2019 Onyx, Black Spinel, VS1 Diamonds, 18K Gold Robin has an
Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Contemporary Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Garnet, Pearl, 18k Gold, Sterling Silver

Lulu Frost Black Silver Dangle Earrings
Located in New York, NY
Product details: Black and silver-tone dangle earrings by Lulu Frost. Crystal embellishments
Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Dangle Earrings

Judith Ripka Black Onyx Sterling Silver Black Onyx Drop Earrings
By Judith Ripka
Located in Scottsdale, AZ
Designer: Judith Ripka Material: sterling silver Gemstone: black onyx Dimensions: each earring
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Unknown Drop Earrings

Materials

Onyx, Sterling Silver

Judith Ripka Black Onyx Sterling Silver Black Onyx Drop Earrings
By Judith Ripka
Located in Scottsdale, AZ
Designer: Judith Ripka Material: sterling silver Gemstone: black onyx Dimensions: each earring
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Onyx, Sterling Silver

.925 Sterling Silver 2.00 Carat Black Diamond Classic Stud Earrings
Located in New York, NY
girlfriends. This beautiful pair of treated black studs are made from the finest .925 sterling silver, and is
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Indian Contemporary Stud Earrings

Materials

Black Diamond, Sterling Silver

Triplet Opal Long Silver Earrings Red Blue Green Black Opal
Located in Berlin, DE
Long silver earrings with triplets of natural Black Opal 6 oval-cut opals, gemstone origin
Category

2010s Artisan Chandelier Earrings

Materials

Opal, Black Opal, Silver

18k Silver Gold Black Sapphire Earrings
By Le Vian
Located in Great Neck, NY
18k & Silver Gold Black Sapphire Earrings
Category

2010s More Earrings

Silver 925 Gold Black Sapphire Earrings
By Le Vian
Located in Great Neck, NY
Silver 925 Gold Black Sapphire Earrings
Category

2010s More Earrings

Silver 925 Gold Black Sapphire Earrings
By Le Vian
Located in Great Neck, NY
Silver 925 Gold Black Sapphire Earrings
Category

2010s More Earrings

3-Tier Black Enamel Simulated Diamond Dangle Sterling Silver Earrings
By Bijoux Num
Located in Los Angeles, CA
Elegant 3-Tier Black Enamel Simulated Diamond Dangle Sterling Silver Earrings These modern-style
Category

2010s American Contemporary Drop Earrings

Materials

Sterling Silver, Enamel, Rhodium

Long black Bakelite clear paste silver drop earrings, France 1920s
Located in Greyabbey, County Down
Very elegant and very nineteen twenties long black Bakelite drop earrings, beautifully sculpted
Category

Vintage 1920s French Art Deco Drop Earrings

Materials

Sterling Silver

Fei Liu Cubic Zirconia Black Rhodium Sterling Silver Drop Earrings
By Fei Liu
Located in Birmingham, GB
. Cascade stud drop earrings shimmering with Hearts and Arrows* cubic zirconia, set in black rhodium plate
Category

21st Century and Contemporary British Contemporary Dangle Earrings

Materials

Other, Rhodium, Silver, Sterling Silver

Amethyst, Black Spinel, Diamonds on Silver and Black Gold Chandelier Earrings
Located in Vannes, FR
Discover this Amethyst, Spinel and White Diamonds Silver and Black Gold Chandelier Earrings
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Unknown Chandelier Earrings

Materials

Amethyst, White Diamond, Spinel, 18k Gold, Silver

.925 Sterling Silver 1/5 Cttw Black Diamond Solitaire Stud Earrings
Located in New York, NY
Delve into the enigmatic allure of these sterling silver stud earrings, each showcasing a mystic
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Indian Modern Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Black Diamond, Rhodium, Sterling Silver

Ippolita Sterling Silver Black Onyx Rock Candy Drop Earrings
By Ippolita
Located in Scottsdale, AZ
Designer: Ippolita Material: sterling silver Dimensions: earrings measure 32 X 15mm Weight: 7.77
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Drop Earrings

Materials

Onyx, Sterling Silver

Victorian Old Mine Diamond Black Onyx Silver Gold Earrings
Located in Stamford, CT
Silver top and 14k yellow gold Victorian 1850 old mine diamond black Onyx handmade earrings. 2
Category

Antique 1850s Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Onyx, 14k Gold, Silver, Yellow Gold

  • 1
  • ...
Get Updated with New Arrivals
Save "Silver Black Earrings", and we’ll notify you when there are new listings in this category.

Silver Black Earrings For Sale on 1stDibs

There is a broad range of silver black earrings for sale on 1stDibs. All of the items for sale were constructed with extraordinary care, often using Silver, Sterling Silver and Gold. Our selection of items includes 243 vintage examples as well as 352 contemporary versions. Our inventory is broad and distinctive, with accessories on offer that were made as long ago as the 18th Century to those produced as recently as the 21st Century. Pieces in our collection of silver black earrings made by Contemporary jewelers — as well as those associated with Modern — are very popular. Many examples in our inventory of these items are appealing no matter their origins, but Meghna Jewels, Chanel and Marina J. produced popular versions that are worth a look. Any of these pieces can lend versatility to your look, but Diamond versions, from our inventory of 168, are particularly popular. Today, if you’re looking for round cut silver black earrings and are unable to find the perfect match, our selection also includes bead and mixed cut alternatives. If you’re browsing the variety of silver black earrings for sale, you’ll find that many are available today for women, but there are still pieces to choose from for men.

How Much are Silver Black Earrings?

Prices for silver black earrings start at $75 and top out at $56,091 with these earrings, on average, selling for $558.

Finding the Right Earrings for You

In the United States, ear piercing didn’t really become popular until the 1950s and ‘60s, but our desire for a dazzling pair of vintage earrings has deeper roots than that. In fact, wearing earrings actually goes back thousands of years, and you can find many tangible connections between now and then in how we continue to talk about these treasured accessories.

Women wore ornamental earrings — studs and hoops at the very least — in Ancient Egypt, which is home to mines that are among the earliest sources of emeralds in the world. Emerald earrings are highly prized today, and their quality lies in their rich, saturated color. The highest-quality emeralds are green or bluish-green. Earrings worn by the affluent in early Roman civilizations were set with precious stones such as diamonds and pearls, and a clean-looking pop of pearl on the front of the lobe is as timeless as ever. Hoop earrings are imbued with symbolism and cultural significance for many, and on view in the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s Ancient Near Eastern Art Gallery is a pair of simple gold hoops from Mesopotamia dating to between 2600 and 2500 B.C.

Today, ear piercing is very popular all over the world, and, as a result, it is difficult to overstate how much everyone pines for a good pair of earrings — modernist drop earrings, glamorous Victorian hoops, geometrically complex chandelier earrings, you name it. Sure, jewelry trends and the fashion darlings of social media come and go, but earrings have a staying power that seems impenetrable: The still-strong love affair between British royals and Cartier earrings is more than a century old, glossy 1970s hoops from legacy houses such as Bulgari and Van Cleef Arpels remain the statement makers they’ve always been and although people have been stacking earrings for many moons, the allure of an expertly mismatched stack of charms and studs still feels fresh and new.

While there is no shortage of modern earring designs to choose from, the classics, like coral earrings, Art Deco–style earrings and diamond drop earrings are still heavy hitters. On 1stDibs, find a wide range of antique, new and vintage earrings today.

Questions About Silver Black Earrings
  • 1stDibs ExpertMarch 13, 2024
    Yes, some Pandora earrings are real silver. The jewelry maker offers a wide range of earrings made of .925 sterling silver. In addition, it offers white, rose and yellow gold pieces. Explore a selection of Pandora jewelry from some of the world's top sellers on 1stDibs.
  • 1stDibs ExpertNovember 14, 2023
    Generally, most experts agree that .925 or 925 sterling silver is the best sterling silver for earrings. This variety of sterling silver is 92.5% pure silver and 7.5% alloy. As a result, it has the cool color and sleek appearance of silver, with another base metal to strengthen it. On 1stDibs, shop a diverse assortment of sterling silver earrings.
  • 1stDibs ExpertDecember 12, 2023
    What silver hoop earrings mean is open to interpretation. Some people associate hoops with power, while others believe they symbolize unity or wholeness. Possible meanings for silver include energy, wealth and modernity. Although there are numerous ways to interpret silver hoop earrings as a symbol, many people wear them simply because they find the jewelry visually appealing rather than to convey a specific message. Shop an assortment of silver hoop earrings on 1stDibs.
  • 1stDibs ExpertNovember 1, 2023
    Yes, sterling silver is okay for earrings. In fact, many people love earrings crafted out of the precious metal. Sterling silver has an appealing cool color and noticeable shine. Plus, the metal is durable, so it can resist scratching when worn frequently. Keep in mind that sterling silver earrings will need regular cleaning and polishing to fight tarnishing. Explore a diverse assortment of sterling silver earrings on 1stDibs.
  • 1stDibs ExpertNovember 14, 2023
    Yes, sterling silver can be good for earrings. Many people appreciate the appearance of sterling silver due to its cool color. In addition, sterling silver resists wear and tear to help earrings stand the test of time. One thing to keep in mind is that silver can tarnish, so you'll likely need to regularly clean and polish your earrings to keep them looking like new. Shop a variety of sterling silver earrings on 1stDibs.
  • 1stDibs ExpertFebruary 7, 2024
    Yes, some Vivienne Westwood earrings are real silver. The British luxury fashion house uses .925 sterling silver to produce some of its pieces. Others feature brass or steel metals. Generally, sterling silver earrings come from the brand's designer collection rather than its fashion jewelry range. Explore a variety of Vivienne Westwood jewelry on 1stDibs.
  • 1stDibs ExpertMay 5, 2023
    To clean Tiffany silver knot earrings, wipe them clean with a soft cloth. Rinse them under warm water and pat them dry with a second cloth. For deeper cleaning, use a spray or liquid cleaner that is safe for sterling silver. Tiffany Co. sells a care kit that provides the essentials for jewelry care. Shop a collection of Tiffany Co. earrings on 1stDibs.
  • 1stDibs ExpertJanuary 23, 2024
    Yes, it is okay to wear sterling silver earrings. Sterling silver has a cool color that many people find appealing, and the metal is durable enough to resist bending and scratching. One thing to keep in mind is that sterling silver can tarnish over time. You can help keep your earrings looking like new by protecting them from water, chlorine and chemicals found in hair care and beauty products. Cleaning your earrings in accordance with the maker's instructions can also reduce the risk of tarnishing. On 1stDibs, explore a selection of sterling silver earrings.
  • 1stDibs ExpertNovember 14, 2023
    To tell if black diamond earrings are real, first examine the surface of the gemstones. Real black diamonds usually have imperfections, while fakes usually appear flawless. Because it can be difficult to identify well-made synthetic gemstones with the naked eye, consider consulting a knowledgeable jeweler, dealer or appraiser for assistance with authentication. Find a variety of black diamond jewelry on 1stDibs.