The practical Fair Isle sweater may be a winter staple as ubiquitous as a puffer jacket or leather pants, but this season it’s anything but predictable. Once mostly confined to classic patterned crewnecks, the iconic knit is stepping out of its comfort zone and into a whole new wardrobe of silhouettes: easy cardigans you can toss over a slip dress, preppy polo sweaters that look sharp under blazers, and plush mohair pieces that turn the familiar motif into something even more cozier. The color palette is evolving, too. Instead of only earthy, traditional shades, shoppers can now find Fair Isle knits in unexpected hues like frosty blue, burgundy red, and neon pink.
To travel back in history, the style takes its name from Fair Isle, an island north of Scotland, where artisans became known for their multicolored banded patterns. Traditionally, these sweaters were knit by hand using local wool and designed to withstand the island’s harsh, wind-whipped climate. Over time, the intricate knit traveled far beyond both the point of origin and its utilitarian purpose, eventually becoming such a winter must-have that most knitwear brands today offer their own interpretations of the look.
Modern versions nod to that heritage while dialing up the fun factor. Designers and labels are breaking the rules with oversize proportions, cropped cuts, and playful pattern placement. As a result, the once-rustic knit now pairs just as easily with a satin skirt and gold jewelry as it does with snow pants and hiking boots. Whether you’re drawn to a classic yoke sweater in a traditional brown or moss hue or tempted by a candy-colored cardigan, there’s a sweater for every aesthetic. Ahead, the very best Fair Isle sweaters that winter 2025 has to offer, plus a few outfit ideas to match.
Styling tip: Double up your sweater game by tying a simpler knit around your waist while actually wearing a Fair Isle companion.
This sweater with a slightly high collar from French-girl brand Sézane is a fashion-insider favorite this season, appearing on feeds everywhere.
The fuzzy texture adds an extra layer of coziness and looks decadent against denim.
A short-sleeve take on the Fair Isle sweater trend.
For extra protection against the elements, this style comes with a turtleneck collar.
This sweater with raglan sleeves and a muted design nods to tradition. It’s also made from extra-fine merino wool.
Burgundy is a big color trend this season, making this cozy cardigan a no-brainer.
Another style with a fluffy finish, this one will go with everything in your closet.
This longline sweater can be worn open as a shawl.
Styling tip: Don't be afraid to break out a bright color in the Fair Isle department.
This Fair Isle sweater works just as well for the holiday parties as Valentine’s Day.
Alex Mill’s knits are a fashion editor-favorite thanks to its high quality.
Frosty blue has never looked more appealing.
This sweater not only hits on the Fair Isle trend but also the polo sweater.
If you want just a pop of burgundy.
You can’t beat the price of this cardigan. Plus: Look at the color!
This Fair Isle cashmere polo could be easily styled for work.
The bold pink hue adds a touch of unexpectedness to the decades-old look.
Styling tip: Match the colors in your sweater to your coat and belt to make an outfit feel more intentional.
No doubt this will keep you warm.
From the cable knit to the bold red hue and polo design, this sweater has everything we want in a winter top.
Too good.
A sportier take on the Fair Isle sweater, this one also works for apres ski looks.
A cheeky sweater with subtle heart prints that nod to Valentine’s Day.
A versatile sweater that looks just as good with jeans as with tailored trousers and skirts.
We love the oversized fit of this Fair Isle cardigan.
This one calls to be styled with brown suede and leather.
Styling tip: Dress up a Fair Isle cardigan for a holiday party by styling it with trousers, sheer tights, and pumps.
Over a mini dress or skirt, this one can double as an evening jacket.
If you prefer a more oversized fit on a Fair Isle, check out the men’s department, where this crewneck is from.
A winter white wonder that will pair nicely with white denim and a fluffy white coat.
Don’t sleep on this majorly discounted Fair Isle gem.
The subtle blue pop adds visual interest to an otherwise neutral sweater.
Grandmacore isn’t going anywhere in 2026.
For the minimalists, this petite sweater has a subtle Fair Isle-inspired design on just the sleeves.
The most expensive pick on this list, it’s also the most luxurious and intricate.